On Non-Monogamy: Do Open Relationships Work?

By: Polly Parker (View Profile)

Our culture believes in love. Sure, people are getting divorced left and right, but we still believe in love. Love is in our stories, and our dreams. Love is in song and prose, in our poetry and art. It makes people feel more intense feelings than anything else does in this world, barring the feeling when you lose someone. But ever when you lose someone, the reason you hurt so much is because you loved him. Love is still the reason. Love is the reason for reasons.

So, again, San Francisco. A lot of people here try and fail at open relationships, just like they do in monogamous relationships. Some succeed. I hear stories all the time. One couple has been together ten years, and open in the last three years. Some couples break up and get back together over and over again. I know a woman who has two kids with her partner, and gets her “night out” every two weeks so she can hook up. I know a couple where the woman is permitted to sleep with other women, not men, just because they see that as something totally unrelated to their marriage. I know another woman who is in a relationship of over ten years, who talks longingly about the time her and her partner had their husband living with them. Apparently, they took him home one night, and he didn’t leave for two years. The three of them slept in a king size bed together.

But no matter what I hear, I still don’t see that any of them are actually happier than couples in monogamous relationships. And I don’t see them staying together longer than their monogamous counterparts. And even if a true-love-non-monogamy thing was possible, why would we even want it? If we see and believe the connection between sex and emotions and love, why would we want to toss it around so casually?

Again, love, people. We are obsessed with it. It’s everywhere, all the time. Everyone wants it. Love is beautiful, all we need is love, (insert the millions of sayings about love here), love is a much splendored thing. Not even death can stop true love, Wesley says in the classic and hilarious The Princess Bride. Death can only delay it. It is the only reason Wesley lives, and the only reason he is brought back from the dead. Love transcends everything. Even the Christians agree—God is love.

7 readers liked this story.
share
bookmarks
Comments
posted: 12.14.2008
Paula Thomas
I believe people have sex with multiple partners to purposely keep themselves from becoming emotionally attached to just one person. This way, they always have a fall back plan just in case the one they're trying to love disappoints them. But, they'll never truly find out if someone really loves them unless they take the chance to be monogomous with them. Besides, why get married in the first place? There had to be something there to say "I do" to forsake all others. That's what truly makes Love so Special - saving it for "the one"
posted: 11.13.2008
Marj K
I don't care if people have polyamorous relationships, I just wish they weren't all crazy evangelical about it. Most of the poly people I've met sound like serial killers, "We're just doing what everyone wants to do, but just don't have the guts/strength/balls to do!" No. Some of us do not want that at all. As for me, I'm happily married and monogomous. I think everyone is entitled to their own opinion and if thier relationship makes them happy and isn't hurting, anyone good for them. However, I kinda think open relationships are choosing warm friendship over committed love. However, for some that, combined with lots of sex, is enough.
posted: 08.13.2008
Tom Farris
Sex is different things to different people. Monogamy is healthy and unhealthy and beautiful and confining...depends on the person, the point that person is at in life, the time of night, etc. For some people it's indistinguishable from love...for others it's a hard wired biological response (red wire connected to the red terminal, black wire to the black terminal...off you go). And, I do know one thing...to assert that people never go to their deathbed wishing they "had had more sex with more people” is just flat ass wrong. There's a reason pornography is a multi-billion dollar industry...people like sex (or at least the idea of sex)...with multiple partners a lot.
posted: 05.09.2008
Robert Erikson
It seems arbitrary over history to make one behavior or another by an adult, or among mutually consenting adults, somehow unrightous if not illegal. Polly uninspiringly joins the crowd regarding non-monogamy. Ironically, she reverses when it comes to smoking. There may be more to life than sex but the same tautologically could be said of anything. But history is constant on one account. Sex will not be denied. When it is, perversion festers. Ask abused Catholic alter boys. If sex will not be not denied, then perhaps placing it in solidarity confinement (monogamy) is the best that those-who-want-to-tell-the-rest-of-us-how-to-live can do. Sure, marriage, kids, dogs and a white pickett fence are fine things too. But as variety in our meals, books, work and entertainment need not be a threat to other good things, neither need be the spice of additional sex partners. If monogamy were a golden answer, divorce in monogamous relationships would be uncommon. On MY deathbed...a satiated smile.
posted: 04.21.2008
Sadie
Did anyone else read the subtext that exists throughout this article? I truly believe Polly is not completely sure what she believes. It's as if she spent the many hours that it took her to construct this piece to talk herself into answering the question her article's title asks "Do Open Relationships Work?". She obviously came to the conclusion "No", which is completely baffling to me since she has not even tried it herself, only relied on the judgments she has passed on her "open" friends' relationships. Interesting indeed! ~Sadie confessionsfrommyopenmarriage.blogspot.com/
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Travel Body & Soul Play Career & Money Neighborhood & World